Peas Through a Lens
This week’s OOTW features today’s OOTD by Budgieye.

SDSS view of SDSS J001340.21+152312.0
This yellow fuzzy galaxy is a Quasar 1.59 billion light years away from Earth in the constellation Pegasus; it’s just above to the left of the star Gamma Pegasi.
When you zoom in with the Keck observatory you’re treated to this beauty:
Now what the Keck telescope can see and the Sloan telescope can’t are the two red smudges in the blue glow of the Quasar. These smudges are in fact one Pea gravitationally lensed by the QSO sitting in front of it! This is the first ever example of a Quasar strongly lensing an object. This is where a galaxy or a cluster of galaxies are so massive that they bend space-time so much that it visibly bends light around them. So the light emitted by an object sitting behind a cluster of galaxies gets bent around the cluster, creating multiple images of one object.
So how can we tell they are multiple images of the same object?
A quote from Budieye’s OOTD:
To ensure that the two red objects on each side of the quasar is actually the same object, each object must have their spectrum taken separately.
Both blobs of red light had identical spectra, indicating that both blobs are the same object, and that the quasar is bending the light from the distant galaxy into two blobs.
Me, HST and the history of surveys
Before I start with a new series of posts, please let me introduce myself.

My name is Boris Häußler (look at my horribly out-of-date website here). I am German but currently working as a research fellow in Nottingham, UK, where I have just recently started my second postdoc with Steven Bamford, whom many people here may know. I have spent the last years (actually, my whole scientific life so far) working on Hubble Space Telescope (HST) data, mainly on the GEMS and STAGES surveys, and have gathered particular experience in the field of galaxy profile fitting, trying to measure sizes, shapes, etc. of distant galaxies. Whereas my previous projects have mainly been working on galaxies at redshift z~0.7, my new job is trying to do similar and more advanced things on more local galaxies, mainly SDSS galaxies, which of course everyone familiar with Galaxy Zoo will know as these are the galaxies classified in both Galaxy Zoo and Galaxy Zoo 2. Initially, one would think that this is a much easier job to do, but as this data is from ground-based telescopes, it proves to be challenging.
This brings me to an interesting position. Although Galaxy Zoo is not my primary science project, I am now connected to the survey through Steven, our galaxy sample and (for now) more directly through this blog. Having worked on HST galaxies for ages, it is of course very interesting for me to see these galaxies now being classified in Galaxy Zoo: Hubble. Having created some of the colour images that both GEMS and STAGES have used for outreach purposes, I have looked at thousands of these galaxies myself and know how stunningly beautiful they can be. I very often got lost on our images, simply browsing around and being fasctinated by the variety of the galaxies. At least in GEMS I know many galaxies by heart and could possibly directly point you to at least some of the brighter and/or more interesting galaxies.
Being kind of an HST expert, Steven has asked if I would want to write a series of posts about HST, an offer that I found hard to turn down, so I’ve decided to write quite a long series about the HST, its history, its future and especially introducing some of the bigger HST surveys, some of which of course build the content of Galaxy Zoo: Hubble now. But before I write and post all this, I would be interested to know what people would actually want to know about Hubble and everything connected with it. So if you have any comments, any wishes, any questions, please post them below and I will try to answer them in the future.
My current plan for the next months contains the following posts, roughly running through the history of Hubble in chronological order:
- Who is Edwin Hubble, the man that gave HST it’s name?
- History of Hubble, the planning and the start 20 years ago
- HST gets spectacles, first service mission
- HDF, the Hubble Deep Field, the first famous survey,
- Another service mission, putting new cameras (e.g. ACS) on HST
- GOODS, the Great Observatories Origins Deep Survey
- GEMS, Galaxy Evolution from Morphologies and SED
- AEGIS , the Deep Extragalactic Evolutionary survey
- HUDF, the Hubble Ultra Deep Survey, the deepest survey ever made
- STAGES, Space Telescope Abell901/902 Galaxy Evolution Survey
- COSMOS, the Cosmic Evolution survey
- The service mission to put in another camera (WFC3)
- Upcoming surveys: CANDELS
- The Future of HST
- HST’s successor, the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST)
If you want to know about anything else, please let me know below.
Thanks and Cheers for now,
Boris
Supernova updates
Hello from the William Herschel Telescope, where I’m observing some of those lovely supernova candidates that have been pouring out of The Supernova Zoo lately.
It’s been a while since our last update. We’ve been running supernova zoo in a very serious way now for several months, and, after ironing out a few little bugs and adding some improvements, the zoo is making a massive contribution to the supernova identification effort in The Palomar Transient Factory. The zoo has already classified some 20,000 supernova candidates, usually several hundred every day; it’s a fabulous effort. You’ve classified every supernova candidate that we’ve put in the zoo!
We also hope that you’re beginning to see feedback on the supernova candidates that you spend your time classifying (at least the better ones!). From this current observing run I’ve been adding comments as I classify the events that you’ve highlighted, so you might see them appearing in your “MySN” area (of course, the more you classify, the more likely this is to happen!).
Here are some of your nice recent finds, all Type Ia Supernovae.
This one seems to live in a galaxy located in a cluster of galaxies:

This is one in a nearby NGC galaxy – the SN is located directly in one of the spiral arms.

And this one is also in a spiral galaxy – but one that is more edge on:

We’re currently preparing a scientific publication that will detail supernova zoo and how it works – and we also have plans to add a new survey to give you even more supernova to play with. So stay tuned!
OK, my exposure has just finished, so I’ll sign off here and go and see what the latest supernova candidate turned out to be!
— Mark
Galaxies spiralling out of control
Today’s OOTW features Alice’s OOTD, posted on the 29th of July.

AHZ40004wr from Hubble Zoo
This is AHZ40004wr, a galaxy residing in the constellation Taurus around 3 billion light years away. It’s a wonderful spiral galaxy, and following its spiral arms is a large dust lane, a place full of young stars and stars that are only just being formed.

AHZ40004wr by Swengineer
Zooite Swengineer gave us a wider view of AHZ40004wr and the surrounding galaxies by working with the FITS images and revealed the mess of galaxies above. The main spiral galaxy in the background is 2MASS J03324999-2734330, an X-ray source according to SIMBAD, and it is also around 3 billion light years away.
You can view more images of these galaxies here and here, and to work with the FITS files I recommend DS9 or Aladin, which I used to find the other galaxies details.
And to highlight a request from Alice’s OOTD, Alice would very much like to know if anyone could write any FITS and image editing tutorials on the galaxy zoo forum.
Zoo 1 data set free
Hi all
It’s taken longer than it should have done – more than three years since the launch of the site – but the data from the original galaxy zoo is now available.
The paper describing the data set was only accepted by the journal yesterday, but we were confident enough after an earlier report to go ahead and make it public. The data can also be downloaded in a variety of formats from our site, or via Casjobs.
The data set is slightly updated from our previous efforts; while we’ve been busy with Galaxy Zoo, the good people of the Sloan Digital Sky Survey produced a new data release which included more spectra, allowing us to estimate biases for more galaxies than ever before.
We’ve had a lot of fun exploring this data set, and we hope that by making it available to all other astronomers then they will make use of your classifications too.
Knowing the Zoo, I wouldn’t be too surprised to see something interesting come from any of you who wanted to have a play – feel free to download and dig in, and let us know how you get on. Meanwhile, the team are working hard on Zoo 2, and hopefully it won’t take as long before that data set too is ready to go.
The Sunflower of Canes Venatici
This galaxy is featured in LizPeter’s OOTD for 24th of July 2010.

M63 from the SDSS
This is Messier 63, though I much prefer its other name, the sunflower galaxy. It’s a wonderful dusty spiral galaxy lying 22.9 million light years away from Earth in the constellation Canes Venatici. It’s one of 7 galaxies bound gravitationally together in the M51 group, and according to Wikipedia, it is one of the first objects to be seen to have spiral arms. This was pointed out in 1845 by William Parsons in a time when these objects were thought to be ‘spiral nebulae’ in our own galaxy, and not galaxies themselves. SIMBAD also claims that there is a cluster of stars lying in the foreground of the galaxy.
There are some brilliant Hubble Legacy images and spectra here, and some more from assorted observatories here!
Observing Red Galaxies With VIRUS-P
Hi Zoo fans,
My name is Peter Yoachim and I’m currently a postdoc working in the Astronomy Department at the University of Texas in Austin.
I got involved with the Galaxy Zoo after I saw Karen’s paper on Red Spirals. When I first read the paper I thought, “Wow, that’s really cool, spirals shouldn’t look red like that, wonder what happened to those galaxies.”, followed shortly by, “OMG, we have the perfect instrument to make follow-up observations of these objects!”
While I’ve been at UT, I’ve been making extensive use of VIRUS-P (Visible Integral-field Replicable Unit Spectrograph Prototype), a new instrument at McDonald Observatory in West Texas. Right now, VIRUS-P is mounted on the 2.7m Harlan J. Smith telescope. While modest in size by current standards, the 2.7m has been a scientific workhorse since 1968 although it is probably most famous for having several bullet holes in the primary mirror.
As I tell my 101 students, images of the sky are a great starting point, but if you want to do Astrophysics, you need to observe some spectra. With galaxies, the full spectra can tell us how different parts of the galaxy are moving (via the redshift and blueshift of light), what kind of stars are in the galaxy, and if there is any hot gas present. VIRUS-P is great for getting spectra, especially for targets like nearby galaxies.
In the bad old days (like when I was doing my thesis work 6 years ago), it was common to pass light from the telescope through a narrow slit, then bounce it off a grating to disperse the light onto the detector to observe the spectrum. The problem is that the narrow slit blocks most of the light from the galaxy. This is a tragedy! That light traveled for (literally) millions of years only to bounce off the slit mask at the last second.
Rather than use a long slit, VIRUS-P uses a fiber-optic bundle to pipe the light around. Here’s an example from a recent paper. NGC 6155 is just a nice normal galaxy, here’s an image of it from the Sloan survey:

When I observe the same galaxy with VIRUS-P, I see this:

Each circle represents a fiber. I’ve color-coded the fibers so that the brightest spectra are blue and the faintest are red. This isn’t too fancy, it even looks quite a bit worse than the Sloan image. But look what happens if I calculate the velocity from the redshift of the spectra in each fiber:

Now we can see the rotation of the disk. The top left of the galaxy is moving away form us, while the bottom right is moving towards us. The redshift of light only shows us the part of the motion that happens to be along our line of sight, but that’s still enough to get a good idea of how the stars and gas in the galaxy orbit the center. The next trick is to add up the spectra from multiple fibers to build up the signal to make it possible to measure accurate ages for the stars.

What we see here is the center of the galaxy is old (~7 billion years), while the disk is young and still forming stars (average age ~4-6 billion years). The youngest section that’s 4 billion years old corresponds to the bright blue spiral arms in the Sloan image. The cool part is the very outskirts of the disk are made of very old stars (8-10 billion years old), a result some of my coauthors actually predicted.
It should be clear now how VIRUS-P will be great for observing the red spirals. We can compare the motions of red spiral disks to regular spirals, and we can measure stellar ages to try and determine when star formation shut off in these galaxies.
The observing of the red spirals has been done by intrepid UT graduate student John Jardel. With the remnants of hurricane Alex blowing through, the observatory has received excessive rain this summer. All that rain makes it hard to observe, plus it lets the rattlesnakes and scorpions thrive. Here’s a scorpion I caught in the observatory lodge last week:

Despite the weather and wildlife, John was able to observe 5 galaxies. We’ve just finished our last observing run of the season, so we haven’t had a chance to analyze the data yet. But looking at the raw images, we already see something interesting:

The horizontal stripes are the signal from each individual fiber. The bright vertical lines are emission lines from the earth’s atmosphere. The two circles show 5 fibers where we can see bright spots. Those spots are emission from hot Hydrogen gas in the galaxy. If there’s gas, it’s possible these red galaxies could start forming stars again and turn back to regular blue spirals. Since the gas is hot and in emission, it could even be the case that there is star formation going on right now.
Markarian and the Blob
Today’s OOTW features an OOTD written by Alice on the 15th of July.
117 million light years away there lies a Markarian galaxy and a very interesting companion. As Alice says in her OOTD, these Markarians are galaxies that emit strongly in ultraviolet and visible light, and are often a host to AGN.
During the observation run at Kitt Peak the Galaxy Zoo team had some spare telescope time going after observing a list of Voorwerpjes, so Bill Keel asked Zooites on the forum to provide objects to get a spectrum for:
The bright blue blobby companion just above the Markarian galaxy MRK 490 centred in the picture above was one such object that was observed. The companion is brimming with new stars as shown by the huge emission line (amongst others) of OIII at around 5000 angstroms in the spectrum below, the object is very close to the galaxy below it going by their redshift, so it is suspected to be interacting with it!
Chandra Program to study Galaxy Zoo Mergers approved
Good news, everyone!
Earlier this year we submitted a proposal to use the Chandra X-ray Observatory to observe a set of merging galaxies in X-rays. The target list for Cycle 12 has just been released, and with a bit of scanning, you can find a set of targets with names like “GZ_Merger_AGN_1”. These targets are a set of beautiful merging galaxies discovered by YOU as part of Galaxy Zoo 1 and the Merger Hunt. The 12 approved targets are here:

These 12 mergers are all very pretty, but they have something else in common: they all host active galactic nuclei (AGN) – feeding supermassive black holes at their centers. X-rays are great for finding such hungry black holes, but we already know that all 12 of these mergers are AGN, so why observe them again? We’re looking for a mythical rare beast: the binary AGN!
Only a handful of these objects are known and they were discovered by chance. We believe that every massive galaxy has a supermassive black hole at its center and so when two galaxies merge, then there should be two black holes around for a while, that is, until they merge. The goal of our Chandra study of these 12 mergers is to systematically search for binary AGN in merging galaxies to work out what fraction of them feature two feeding black holes. Knowing whether such phases are common or not is important for understanding how black holes interact with galaxies in mergers and what exactly happens to them as they plunge towards the center of the new galaxies where they are doomed to merge and form a single supermassive black hole.
As usual, it may be quite a while before we get the data. The observing cycle won’t start for a while and takes about a year. Since our observations are short and we don’t have any time constraints (they’re galaxies, they don’t move!) the Chandra operators will most likely schedule our observations in between longer projects and time sensitive observations and so we won’t know when they will happen. Of course, once we do get the data, we’ll definitely update you.
Oh and you might notice some of the targets in the Merger Zoo in the near future. We’ll need your help to fully understand them….
Happy birthday to us.
Galaxy Zoo is three years old today. Three years ago, I opened my laptop in the back of a Royal Astronomical Society meeting, connected my laptop to the rather flakey wifi network and noticed the site had crashed under the sheer weight of demand.
Three years on, we’ve produced excellent science, have moved on to the distant Universe, built the Zooniverse and, thanks to the contributions of every single person who has ever classified a galaxy, established that involving the public in research is an excellent way to get things done. Here’s to the next three years.
Chris
P.S. You can hear Kevin and I discussing his work on active galaxies on today’s 365 days of astronomy podcast.
P.P.S. Thanks in particular to the forum for their birthday cards and best wishes.




